A new knee that won’t progress: sometimes old scars and skipped medicine

·

Updated

A new knee that won't progress: sometimes old scars and skipped medicine

That morning, a man on crutches came into the clinic, taking each step with care. His left knee had just been replaced, and the incision was still fresh. Sitting down to tell his story, he said he had been on the operating table several times before, and still had scars on his face, his lower back and under his chin. Those scars sounded like something from years past, with nothing to do with the new knee.

The first four sessions after knee replacement

In the first session, the doctor guided him through knee movement exercises, but the knee could bend and straighten only within a very small range. He had a lot of pain at the upper attachment of the quadriceps and along the incision. The session ended with a few gentle Applied Kinesiology (AK) techniques; the doctor prescribed medicine to help ease the pain and told him to go home and rest.

At the end of the second session, the doctor adjusted his diet, told him to take extra micronutrients, and showed him a few more exercises to do at home.

By the third session, he no longer needed the crutches, but how far the knee could bend, and the pain, were almost the same as in the two sessions before. This time the doctor did AK first and only then had him exercise. Muscle testing showed that the old scars were also helping to hold the knee back, through medicinal substances, nutrition and nerve receptors alike. Once those parts were dealt with, the knee bent and straightened through a clearly wider range, and exercising became much easier for him.

In the fourth session, the pain was down to one small area, but the range was worse than the session before, and every time he brought his thighs together, his buttock gave a sharp twinge. Only after careful questioning did it come out that he had been away on a work trip a few days earlier and had skipped his medicine for several days in a row. The doctor had him take the medicine right there in the clinic, then checked again: bringing the thighs together regained its range, and the buttock pain was gone too. Next, the doctor dealt with the scars on his face, lower back and under his chin, and the knee’s range of motion improved a great deal. He now walks and moves around much more comfortably than before.

In every session, he exercised and had many things adjusted at the same time, so we cannot say how much treating the scars contributed and how much the medicine did. One person’s story is also not enough to speak for everyone who has a joint replaced. Still, since this case, when the doctor meets a knee that keeps exercising without making progress, the doctor also asks whether the patient has any other scars on the body and whether they are taking their medicine regularly.

Pain that lingers after knee replacement is fairly common

Many people think the pain will be gone about three months after surgery. With an artificial knee, that is only a rough marker, and some people have pain for much longer. The systematic review by Beswick and colleagues (2012) pooled studies that followed people who had joint replacement for osteoarthritis from 3 months up to 5 years: about 10%–34% of people with a knee replacement still had long-term pain; in the studies of the best quality, the figure was about 20%, or one person in every five.

Wylde and colleagues (2011) followed up with 632 people 3–4 years after knee replacement: 44% still had some degree of pain, and 15% had severe to very severe pain. The research team found two factors that went along with long-lasting pain: severe depression, and having many other painful areas in the body. That is also why, when examining a newly replaced knee, the doctor still asks about other places in the body.

What do scars on the face or back have to do with the knee?

A scar that has healed on the skin is still an area of tissue that was once cut, stitched and then pulled tight as it knit together, along with the nerve endings that lie within it. Our article on C-section scars described how a scar can affect areas far away from it. In people who have had many operations, muscle testing sometimes finds a few old scars that are still making a muscle group elsewhere weak. Just stepping up onto a single stair, the thigh muscles have to straighten the knee, the buttock muscles hold the hip steady, and the trunk muscles keep the body upright. If one of those groups weakens, a newly replaced knee already finds it hard to bend.

After surgery, the nervous system can also keep the injured area in a protective state for quite a long time, as our article on muscles that stay tense long after an old injury explained; in the case above, the nerve receptors were also part of what the doctor had to treat.

A few days without medicine, and the knee bends less

For a micronutrient or an herb being considered as an addition, the doctor may place a little on the tip of your tongue and then measure the knee’s bending angle again, following the way the chemical side of the health triangle is checked (Walther, 1981, pp. 45–50). The body responds right there in front of you, so both the doctor and the patient can see how far that substance is supporting the knee, just like the time he took his medicine at the clinic in the fourth session.

People who have just had surgery often take many things at once: medicine prescribed by the orthopedic side, plus medicine and micronutrients from the clinic. A trip of a few days or a change in daily routine makes it easy to miss some. Medicine from your surgeon should be taken exactly as instructed until your follow-up visit; anyone taking blood thinners after surgery needs to ask their doctor before adding any medicine, herb or micronutrient.

A swollen, hot knee or a tight, painful calf: don’t wait for the next session

If you have any of the following signs, call your surgeon today; don’t wait for your follow-up appointment.

  • The knee is clearly more swollen, hot and red than in the past few days;
  • Fever;
  • Fluid draining from the incision.

A calf on one side that is swollen, tight and painful, or sudden shortness of breath or chest pain, means you must go to the emergency department, because there may already be a blood clot in the leg or in the lung.

What the doctor looks at before the knee starts exercising

Your hospital discharge papers, the date of surgery and your surgeon’s instructions on how far the knee may bend and how much weight it may bear are the first things the doctor reads. After that come measuring the range of bending and straightening, looking at the incision, pulse diagnosis, tongue diagnosis, and questions about previous operations and the medicines you are taking. Knee movement exercises are part of the AK session: the doctor guides each movement and uses the measured bending angle to decide whether to keep exercising or stop.

Worth keeping

  • Once a week, note the distance from your heel to your buttock when you bend the knee, so you know whether you are moving forward or standing still;
  • Tell the doctor about every previous operation, including small scars on the face, chin and back;
  • Sort your medicine into a daily pill box and bring enough with you on work trips;
  • Exercise only to the degree of bending your surgeon allows at each stage;
  • A swollen, painful calf, shortness of breath or chest pain means going to the emergency department right away.

Your first exercise session at the clinic can start once your surgeon has allowed you to move the knee; from then on, Dr. Dinh Ngoc Duc (MD, MSc in Traditional Medicine) will work in line with the exercise plan your surgeon has given you.

References

  1. Beswick AD, Wylde V, Gooberman-Hill R, Blom A, Dieppe P (2012). What proportion of patients report long-term pain after total hip or knee replacement for osteoarthritis? A systematic review of prospective studies in unselected patients. BMJ Open 2(1):e000435. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2011-000435
  2. Wylde V, Hewlett S, Learmonth ID, Dieppe P (2011). Persistent pain after joint replacement: prevalence, sensory qualities, and postoperative determinants. Pain 152(3):566-572. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pain.2010.11.023
  3. Walther DS (1981). Applied Kinesiology, Volume I – Basic Procedures and Muscle Testing. Pueblo: Systems DC. Chapter Chemical and Nutrition Testing, pp. 45–50.

Book a consultation at Tam Duc Clinic

Leave your details and the clinic will message you in English to confirm your appointment.